Clicky

7 Favorite Casual Restaurants In Belmar

From steamed lobster pots and signature salads, to super-sized sandwiches and smothered burritos, Belmar, New Jersey, has a variety of casual dining options for hungry families. Here are some popular places to check out when you're looking for lunch or a light bite.

1. Comfi of Belmar

707 Main Street

Belmar, New Jersey

732-749-3583

Specialty: Breakfast, brunch, and lunch

Comfi of Belmar is one of our go-to spots for breakfast and lunch, and we love to ride our bikes there in the summer. On a recent visit, Comfi's "And Then I Met You" sandwich provided a generous serving of grilled turkey topped with egg whites, melted pepper jack cheese, and guacamole. Served on a hearty multi-grain bread with sweet potato fries. Add bacon and Sriracha sauce to make this sandwich over the top! In accordance with state COVID-19 guidelines, Comfi is currently offering limited-capacity indoor dining, as well as outdoor dining for larger groups up to eight people. Curbside pickup and takeout are also available.

The belly-busting "And Then I Met You" sandwich with sweet potato fries at Comfi in Belmar, New Jersey

2. Federici's on 10th

705 10th Ave

Belmar, New Jersey

732-681-3337

Specialty: Thin-crust pizza and Italian food

www.fedspizza.com


If you're fond of anything prepared in the Francaise style, you must try the Francaise sauce at Federici's on 10th Avenue in Belmar. Their Francaise sauce is the best I have ever eaten! Try the artichokes Francaise for a sample of Fed's velvety lemon-butter sauce — or go all in with an order of chicken Francaise. The vodka sauce pizza with a Shanna Salad on the side are also highly recommended, along with the daily selection of fresh hot soups.


Feds on 10th has shaded outdoor seating under a canopy, as well as limited indoor dining. Reservations via Open Table are required. The restaurant is not taking reservations over the phone. Takeout is also available but no delivery.


Current hours for summer 2020 are: Wednesday to Monday, 12:00 p.m. to 9:00 p.m. The last seating time is 8:30 p.m. Closed on Tuesday.

Catering tray of the amazing chicken Francaise (with extra sauce) at Fed's on 10th in Belmar.

3. Hoagitos

807 Belmar Plaza

Belmar, New Jersey

732-556-6617

Specialty: Gourmet mini hoagies (subs)

www.hoagitos.com


"Small size, big flavor" is the motto at Hoagitos, which is located in Belmar Plaza, a few doors down from 10th Ave. Burrito Co. The sweet-and-spicy glaze on their "Forbidden Chicken" sandwich is a personal favorite, along with their "Southern Comfort" panko fried chicken sandwich topped with griddle macaroni and cheese (oh my!).


The Hoagitos dining room is currently closed during the coronavirus pandemic, but you may order online and pick it up or have it delivered.


Hoagitos was featured on Season 11 of the Travel Channel's "Food Paradise."


RELATED: Best Spots For Outdoor Dining In Belmar

The amazing "Forbidden Chicken" sandwich at Hoagitos in Belmar.

4. Jake's Downtown

803 Main Street

Belmar, New Jersey

848-404-9834

Specialty: Fried seafood platters, clam bakes, lobster pots, po' boys

www.jakesdowntown.com


Jake's Downtown offers a casual backdrop for a fresh seafood feast. Jake's is a culinary endeavor of renowned local chef Chris Brandl, who also owns his namesake Brandl Restaurant in downtown Belmar. Jake's is locally known for its fish and chips, raw bar, and lobster pots.


The menu also includes clam chowder and lobster bisque, as well as steamed and baked shellfish, oyster po' boys, Belmar style lobster rolls, crab cake sandwiches, and more. In addition to a small outdoor seating area on Main Street, Jake's has socially distanced tables inside. Takeout and local delivery service are also available.

Samples of French fries and crispy crab balls from Jakes Downtown in Belmar.

5. La Terrazza Cucina Rustica & Bar

408 Ocean Avenue

Belmar, New Jersey 732-894-3855

Specialty: Italian food, pizza, pasta

Website

La Terrazza is the place to go in Belmar for Italian favorites with an ocean view. Located on Ocean Avenue right next door to the popular La Dolce Vita Italian Restaurant, La Terrazza is a great destination for lunch or dinner with appetizers, pasta dishes, pizza, and more. During a visit after the Belmar Kite Festival last fall, the arugula and prosciutto flatbread was a great selection for lunch. Current hours are 11:30 a.m. to 10:00 p.m. seven days a week. Lunch is served from opening until 3:00 p.m.

RELATED: Outdoor Dining With A Water View In Belmar, NJ

Flatbread with arugula and prosciutto at La Terrazza.

6. 10th Avenue Burrito Co.

801 Belmar Plaza

Belmar, New Jersey

732-280-1515

Specialty: Tex-Mex

www.tenthaveburritoco.com


Local and visitors alike enjoy gathering for a casual meal at 10th Avenue Burrito Co. in downtown Belmar, New Jersey. Our favorites here include the sweet and spicy corn soup, pineapple-habañero wings, pork molé nachos, and shrimp in tequila-lime sauce. For summer 2020, 10th Ave. Burrito Co. has outdoor seating under a covered patio and tables in the Belmar Plaza parking lot. Indoor seating also resumed on September 4.

In 2010, owner Brian Katz shared his secrets to a great adobo sauce during a taping of Food Network's "Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives," with host Guy Fieri. RELATED: Taste Of Belmar - Spicy Tomatillo Salsa Recipe From 10th Avenue Burrito

Chicken and black bean burrito at 10th Ave. Burrito Co. in Belmar, New Jersey.

7. Stay Gold Café

800 Main Street

Belmar, New Jersey

732-894-9270

Specialty: Bistro-style sandwiches, salads, smoothies, breakfast, acai bowls, vegan options, and coffee drinks

www.staygoldcafe.com


In addition to seasonal specials, the menu at Stay Gold Café includes small plates for sharing, sandwiches, salads, smoothies, acai bowls, French toast, breakfast sandwiches, fresh juice, and gourmet coffee drinks. Personal favorites include the Dirty Monkey peanut butter-banana smoothie with almond milk and the chicken salad with walnuts, apples and cranberries.

RELATED: 8 Great Breakfast Restaurants In the Belmar Area

Outdoor seating at Stay Gold Café in downtown Belmar.

Live Like A Local: Rent A Belmar Beach House

Day trips down the shore are fun, but it's even better to rent a beach house for the week to experience everything wonderful about the Belmar area. For couples, solo adults and small families, the two-bedroom Blue Hydrangea Cottage rental in Belmar, New Jersey, is the perfect getaway place. The home sleeps up to four people and is consistently rated five stars for comfort, cleanliness, amenities, location, and homelike decor. Learn more at www.vacationinbelmar.com. Weekly summer rentals at the Jersey Shore. Rent directly from the owner and save!

Story and photos © copyright by Christine Cardellino, owner of www.vacationinbelmar.com and publisher of the award-winning Belmar Beachcomber Blog, a travel and tourism guide for the Belmar region of the Jersey Shore. Do not copy any content (including images) without our permission. All rights reserved.

  • Facebook

The award-winning Belmar Beachcomber Blog is written and produced by Christine Cardellino, owner of VacationInBelmar.com

©Copyrighted material. Do not copy content (including images) without our permission. All rights reserved.

Contact Us